It is not a matter of nature or nurture, it is the nature of nurture that matters.
In nature what holds intrinsic value nurtures itself unmolested by man. Mans nature is to nurture and it will often naturally create value in his own mind where none actually exists. In marketing this is observed as creating a market and then marketing to it. One such market, is the animal rescue industry. Animal rescue organizations, are founded to address the problem they themselves have created and these organizations are built on a natural desire to help, reflected in the reality that they are largely a volunteer/slave labor force. Dedicated souls, tirelessly searching for adoptive pet parents, while simultaneously overwhelmed by an endless supply of unwanted pets that have resulted by their own actions and beliefs. The contemptible aspect of it all, is that this is a marketing scheme, designed and propagated by the animal care and supply industry who intentionally created a conundrum that naturally exploits mans nature to nurture and then sentences us all to a infinite struggle over trying to solve the issue of whether nature verses nurture. A struggle that can’t be won only perpetuated because in nature itself, this conflict does not exist. Fostering this plight is akin to tasking us to determine which side of the same coin has the greatest influence on its overall value. Drowning in a unending sea of unwanted pets, the debate is an infinitely repeating decimal locked in the nature of mans evil marketing genius. The question and debate over what causes dangerous dogs, is not one of which is it, nature or nurture, yet paradoxically, if it where, the answer is a resounding yes.
Nature is the mechanics of those things that occur in the environment outside of mans influence. The influence of these natural mechanics upon living beings are called instincts. A species is a living being that possesses different instinctual traits one from another species but is perpetually driven by naturally occurring and reoccurring impulses to reproduce only with others like itself who posses those traits that are unique only to their own kind. Where the domestic canine is concerned, the species begins and ends where any two domestic canines regardless of their particular breed Pit bull to Poodle, will by natural instinct mate to any other domestic canine breed. Breeding is an act by man who discriminates between and chooses among, a collection of naturally occurring instinctual traits possessed by the domestic canines he pairs , in order to nurture predictable behavioral and physical outcome in them. In the dog world, the resulting canines are called a dog breed and they are distinguished one from another by virtue of the fact that the resulting bred dogs, lack an inherit instinct to reproduce only like dog breeds. Simply stated, if man wants another Poodle-or any specific dog breed for that matter – he must breed another Poodle, each time, every time. Breeding is the outcome of the nature of what man wants not the nature of what the animal naturally wants. Humans who engage in this activity are called breeders.
Man nurtures the breed process along by using dogs with specific instinctual group traits so as to produce dogs that will be born with a natural desire to perform the tasks man wishes to train them to do. Training is merely the completion of the harmony that nurtures this behavior by directing those dog to the tasks they innately are born and breed to do. This understanding is why you have never seen a Norman Rockwell painting of a Pit bull pointing quail or retrieving a duck . Rabbit hunters seek breeders of beagles to obtain dogs that can readily be directed to hunt rabbits. Not all canines can be trained to do this and for those where it may even be possible, the value in expending such effort into a training regime yields a highly diminished return. Especially when contrasted against a beagle that requires only that you release it a field . Nowhere can we observe the perversion of natural harmony then in the efforts by some to promote and who attempt to use obedience training to disrupt the flow of naturally inbred instincts in Pit bull dogs. Fueled by mans natural resistance of nature there is the complete contradiction of nature and a failing to accept that the unprecedented carnage and fatalities among humans, pets and Pit bull dogs alike is a natural result of his nurturing and engineering nature. Obedience training is not the changing of instinct, obedience training is nothing more then mans lording over a dog. Mans refusal to be obedient to nature is paradoxically reflected in the nature of the Pit bulls he has engineered and remains infinitely the nature of their beast.